Failing Big

I’m a “perfectionist.” When I say that I don’t mean I think I’m perfect. Actually, I feel far from it. Perfectionism, for me, means that I set unreasonably high expectations for myself, mostly with regard to my character and/or my ability to achieve; expectations that are nearly impossible to reach or maintain. Inevitably, when I don’t reach these expectations, I’m left feeling less than (which is pretty much always). I have a tremendously difficult time showing myself the grace, compassion, and forgiveness that I would to others. Essentially, I have one a set of standards for the world, and then a completely separate set of standards for myself. Perfectionism leaves me in a constant state of feeling like I’m moments away from losing everything, like I’m never good enough. I am habitually and shamefully insecure.

Needless to say, this hasn’t served me well and prohibits me from being the person I want to be. I realize it is self-indulgent thinking, kind of ridiculous, and ultimately tends to paralyze me. There, of course, have been times when perfectionism has helped me. It has kept me aiming and reaching, trying to achieve. It is what made me a good student. Achieving things helped me to feel validated…but only momentarily.

Mostly though, perfectionism causes me to be self-destructive. “I’ll never be good enough so why even try?” The fear of failure is so huge for me. When I fail, I take it personally. I use it as ammunition to reinforce a false narrative that I’m just a piece-of-shit human being. I can trace my life into moments when I am leaning into my perfectionism acquiring validation from achievement and moments when I rebel against my perfectionism, give up, and stop trying all together. Very rarely am I peacefully floating in the middle; a beautiful realm where I try my best at something and risk failing at it.   

I’ve had to reevaluate all this recently. Well, first I just evaluated it because, to be honest, I wasn’t aware that this was a pattern of thinking for me. I knew I was hyper critical of myself but I didn’t identify that my doing this was an attempt to preserve and protect myself. I was subconsciously “keeping myself in line” because the pain of feeling like a “fuck-up” was too risky.

Lately, I’ve been failing in a very big way. Potentially the biggest failure of my life. And it is so incredibly painful that I’ve felt that I might suffocate from my own self-hatred.

Every month, for the past 3.5 years, I take a test…and I fail that test. One fucking line with a stark white space where there should be a second. I can’t make sense of it. I torture myself about it. I feel terrible guilt about the debt I have put my husband and I in trying to fix it, and yet, failing to do so. I hate that I’m in a profession that esteems health while I’m simultaneously battling my own. I’m resentful of the judgment and pity I receive from others; the unwarranted advice from those who’ve never experienced infertility. It’s been a complete shame-fest of a nightmare and I desperately want to run away from it.  

But…I’ve been forced to make peace with it (albeit kicking and screaming). I have been made to confront failure again, and again, and again, in a painfully laughable way. It is as if the universe is saying, “See. This isn’t killing you. This thing you are so scared of: failing…failing big. You’re doing it over and over again. And guess what? It doesn’t kill you! Stop being scared. This is where you become who you’re meant to be. Failure is how I am going to teach you.”

With failure as my teacher, I’ve been learning a lot about myself. I have learned that I can handle hard things; I can survive difficult circumstances. I’ve also learned that there is no amount of pain that makes you immune to more pain and you must endure the suffering of life in order to experience the beauty of life. And lastly, I’ve learned that I know how to pick myself up, again and again and that I’m more resilient than I thought I was.

Suffering is part of the human experience. I know there is suffering I haven’t yet faced which is an overwhelmingly difficult truth to bear. We can wallow in our pain (which I sure did and still do sometimes) but we can also use it as fuel to propel us towards gratitude and connection. My pain and my failure only make me more human. It levels me. It brings me back to earth.  

Over the past year I have realized that everyone is waiting on something. Waiting for a solution to an unanswered question. Why did this or that happen? When will this or that happen? How will I make it through? What will it be like? It doesn’t matter whether the source of the question is infertility, death, divorce, infidelity, singleness, debt, unemployment, illness, addiction, bullying etc. There is humanness in the pain of wondering and waiting. We are connected, not because we can always identify ourselves in each other’s unique experiences, but because we know on a visceral level what suffering feels like.

So I have been thinking about ways in which I let the fear of failure run my life. I’ve been thinking about the bag of shame I carry and the contents I never expose. I’ve been thinking about how my unwillingness to be vulnerable keeps me from being my most authentic self and connecting to others in a real way.

It is an indelible truth that failure will not kill me. I learn this lesson again and again.  And so I’ve been looking at the ways in which I have been avoiding failure. The truth is, I feel much more comfortable when I blend in, when I’m anonymous, when I’m unmemorable. It’s safe. But that’s the problem. I can’t possibly give to the world if I’m not showing up in it.

I thought I would start here. It is consistently on my heart to write (and share what I write) but I am quite the gopher when it comes to blogging. I’ll pop out every once in a while and share something vulnerable, get scared and climb back into the ground to hide. The fear is that no one will read it, that I will be judged, or that what I’m writing isn’t good or interesting enough. It’s a legitimate fear because all those things are likely to be true. But so what? I have been failing so big lately and still surviving. Why not try and fail at this too?

By doing this—doing something that is on my heart to do but knowing that there is a great potential I will not meet my own expectation—I will be in that beautiful middle ground. I will be defying the trappings of perfectionism. And by showing my scars and my pain…I will hopefully be able to connect to others who have wounds that need healing too.

Miracle Formulas, Anti-Feminist Marketing, and The Wellness Industry

If you’re anything like me, you may have watched Lo Bosworth in the early 2000’s on Laguna Beach and then The Hills. She was Lauren Conrad’s bestie. A few years ago she had a YouTube channel which I became interested in because she was in culinary school and provided food demonstrations that were somewhat useful and entertaining. (She later deleted them all which I never understood.)

I follow her on Instagram and she recently uploaded a video discussing her new brand LoveWellness which she describes as being a “modern, female-first, personal care brand.” When discussing why she started the brand she states, “I kept going to the drug store and I was so disappointed by what was offered for women. I felt like it was archaic, and everything was full of chemicals, and didn’t work, and anti-feminist in the messaging and in the advertising, and is something that I wanted to change.”

Awesome, right?

I went to the website to check out the products because I love supporting female entrepreneurs and brands that are looking to change the way we advertise to women. The website is selling everything from probiotics to vaginal health kits.

Here is the thing: we have to be wary of the “wellness” industry in general. It seems progressive but it is similar to what the diet industry was 15 years ago. Sure it is selling you something new and different but the marketing techniques are the same: if you’re a woman you should want to be thin, happy and youthful. A brand that labels themselves “feminist” and then names their digestive enzyme “Bye Bye Bloat” and claims that it will help you “slim down” is misleading. “Good Girl Probiotic” is also missing the feminist mark. And the most interesting one of all, “The Lean Queen” that has been renamed to “Metabolove” to be more “body positive.” I guess someone in their marketing department recognized that demonstrably promoting thinness isn’t necessarily in line with their self-proclaimed feminist ideology!? But lets be honest, the selling point of “Metabolove” is the same: weight loss. The website claims it is the “metabolism maintenance your body craves” and “perfect for getting back on track for life’s big moments.” The implication being either A.) you need to be “on track” (and by “on track” they mean in specific shape or form) for life’s big moments like the engagement, the 30th birthday, the vacation; or B.) that having the slice of cake on your friend’s birthday or a glass of champagne at a wedding is “off track” and in some way in need of being remedied…hopefully by their product.

I can read between the lines with these advertisements (slathered with a “natural,” “organic,” “holistic,” hue to make it seem as though the brand actually cares about your health) but this type of marketing affects young, vulnerable girls who are taught to believe their worth and value is inherent in how they appear. Sadly, some of these young girls will become adult women who are still manipulated by the same thing. Brands that market products to women with a false promise of thinness, happiness, and youth (instead of just being honest about what their products do and trusting that we’re smart enough to understand) are perpetuating a false belief that those are things women need to achieve…and that their product can help them achieve it.

I don’t believe that wanting to look your best or try new beauty products is anti-feminist (and I certainly don’t claim to be an expert when it comes to feminist theory). What I think is unfortunate is selling a product based on a falsehood of thinness and claiming that your advertising is different. Women have been sold thinness for eons; this is not revolutionary marketing.

Lets take the “Bye Bye Bloat” digestive enzyme as an example. The bottle says the product is “digestive enzymes and organic ingredients to help you slim down and de-bloat.” The website also says it’s a “miracle formula” that’s “perfect for conquering big meals.” I’m uncomfortable already.

Firstly, if you are someone who is bloated to the point where you are in pain and experiencing extreme discomfort after meals, you should be consulting a physician, not Lo Bosworth. But that’s not the type of bloating the product seems to be talking about here. As the marketing on the product and website suggests, this is the type of bloating a woman might experience after a “big meal.” The implication is that you shouldn’t be having “big meals.” However, if you do—because you were “bad” and have no self-control—(not really, you’re just human and have biological needs and “big” is an ambiguous term anyway...) and your stomach is distended, you can take their product to help de-bloat. It’s, as they’ve said, a “miracle.”

Even though the slight, natural distention someone might feel after meals can be completely normal, many people come to have a complicated relationship with this sensation and believe that it needs to be remedied. It’s important to acknowledge that the sensation we have after meals is likely going to be different than how we feel before meals. But if we are relaxed and comfortable (and without any other underlying medical issues that may impact digestion) our bodies are going to do a great job of remedying that slight, natural distention on its own.

Digestive enzymes are naturally occurring in our bodies (primarily our pancreas, mouth, stomach, and small intestine) and they are secreted to help break food down so we can absorb the nutrients. Sometimes the body does not make enough digestive enzymes which can slow digestion and cause uncomfortable symptoms. For example, if you’re not producing enough lactase you may have a difficult time breaking down lactose. In this case taking a nonprescription digestive enzyme (a lactase supplement like Lactrase) could be beneficial. Chronic conditions such as cystic fibrosis or chronic pancreatitis can lead to low levels of digestive enzymes as well (in which case prescriptive doses of digestive enzymes are often prescribed).

However, there is limited evidence suggesting that digestive enzymes alone will promote significant weight loss, yet that is exactly how the product is being marketed. To help you “slim down.”

Why?

That’s precisely the question we should be asking ourselves. Why are brands continuing to sell women a false promise of thinness? Why are we, as consumers, so invested in the idea of thinness? And how are we continuing to contribute to the false narrative that thinness is a female expectation?

Obviously there are specific situations when taking a digestive enzyme or probiotic can be useful (but honestly, even their probiotic doesn’t enthuse me; the label doesn’t list the strains of bacteria that are used so you can’t be sure of the effectiveness. Check out https://kelseykinney.com/best-probiotic-strains/ for more thorough information on probiotic strains).

There are many brands that use thinness and beauty as a way to market to female consumers. I think my biggest cause of concern with this brand in particular is the messaging that it was changing the way we, as women, are being marketed to. Come on! This brand is using the same techniques that have always been used to market to women. Just because you’re selling vaginal health kits doesn’t mean your advertising is feminist.

Although it seems like minutiae, we have to acknowledge blatant contradictions in messaging like this. We have to become more aware of how we are potentially being manipulated by the guise of false promises. If we do so, we can hopefully prevent younger girls and women from falling victim to the same, unproductive narrative: that as woman, we should be small, in form and in opinion.

“A culture fixated on female thinness is not an obsession about female beauty, but an obsession about female obedience. Dieting is the most potent political sedative in women’s history; a quietly mad population is a tractable one.” Naomi Wolfe

Endometriosis and Infertility

I wrote this essay in May of 2019 after receiving an endometriosis diagnosis.

In a world where we over share, I hesitate with this. This is too close to my heart and potentially too personal. A funny picture of my dogs, a moment of affection between my husband and I, a delicious meal perfectly plated…you can have every inch of it. You may like it or reject it (but lets be honest, most of us don’t share with the intention of being rejected.) Sharing publically is a quiet plea for acknowledgement and acceptance; yet, it is also an act of courage and vulnerability made easier when the stakes are lower.

This feels too much. I have experienced—and, in my opinion, in large part due to the fact that I am a woman—that being “too much” (too opinionated, too loud, too smart, too funny, too big, even) is almost more unlikeable than being less than enough. And so we learn to make ourselves smaller and quiet experiences that may be seen as such. 

Unfortunately, we reinforce shame and embarrassment when we do this, not only within ourselves but also in people with similar experiences. Shame and embarrassment are primary reasons that people neglect to seek medical care and so I’m learning the importance of sharing personal experiences, even at the risk of rejection. By doing so, we open avenues for people to feel more safe, comfortable, and confident to discuss things that may otherwise be seen as “too much.” If one person reads this and seeks medical care sooner, it would be worth the number of people who read this and find it unbearably self-indulgent (which in fact, it feels).

Close friends and family already know (and I am sure a sprinkling of random individuals who I inappropriately over-shared with). This has been all-consuming after all…and a pot with a lid only boils for so long before it bursts. And I did just that.  Several times.

In the beginning of February of this year, after two and a half years of unsuccessfully trying to conceive on our own, my husband, Rob, and I underwent our first IVF cycle, which inevitably failed. It wasn’t just a failed cycle; it was as one doctor put it, a cycle that had “terrible outcomes.” IVF, or in vitro fertilization, is the process of extracting the woman’s eggs, retrieving a sperm specimen, and combining them together in a petri dish. You then transfer the embryo back into the woman’s uterus and hope that it will implant itself to create a successful pregnancy. IVF involves giving yourself injections multiple times daily, frequent blood draws and intravaginal ultrasounds, and going under anesthesia for the egg retrieval. Its really expensive, not always covered by insurance and doesn’t always work. 

When I woke up from anesthesia after the egg-retrieval I was wheeled to an isolated area where I sat behind a curtain waiting for the doctor. I remember one of the nurses asking me what shows on Netflix I wanted to watch when I got home. Even in a groggy- medicated-stupor I over-thought my response. I knew I had already binged the shows I wanted to see so I would be relegated to Bravo re-runs. However confident in my answer, I hesitated to tell the nurse because I didn’t have the enthusiasm to explain that you can be a feminist and watch The Real Housewives franchise...just ask Roxane Gay.  

Separated by thin, draping fabric, I heard the doctor speak to the patient next to me. I also heard that patient cry when the doctor left. The nurse entered to console her and said, “its still not over.” I felt compassion for that woman but I also desperately did not want to be her. I did not want to be an infertile woman crying about my body’s inability to work properly. There are too many terrible things in this world for me—someone with a decent amount of privilege, living a comfortable and safe life—to feel sorry for myself over this. I had deep empathy for that woman, but very little for myself. “How am I sitting here wearing this weird mesh hair-net, naked under a hospital gown, with these little, stupid booties on, going through IVF? Me? I’m 29! I’m healthy!”

The doctor then entered my curtained area and told me they were only able to retrieve eight eggs. “It was less than expected,” she said. When the doctor left the nurse entered and went over discharge instructions with me. I remember her aggressively questioning me: “Why are you shaking?” I was cold, not seizing like she thought. But even my shivering was “too much,” too dramatic.

Eight eggs. That’s not a lot. Some women get 27 eggs. I knew because I had been following people’s IVF journeys on Instagram and YouTube. I wondered why I only got eight. I was perplexed but still hopeful. I worried but I did not cry. I was numb.

I learned that IVF is a numbers game. The more eggs you have the better chances that more eggs will be fertilized and therefore there will be more to chose from when transferring. Any embryos that aren’t transferred back into the woman’s uterus can be frozen and used during another cycle. So the fact that I only had eight eggs retrieved decreased the chances of having embryos make it to transfer let alone having any to freeze.

Ultimately, three eggs fertilized normally and only one embryo made it to transfer day, which was five days after the retrieval. One embryo. All of those legal documents regarding frozen embryos were null. The questions about what we would do with our frozen embryos in the case that Rob or I died, if we both died, if we got a divorce, etc. were trashed. We wouldn’t have any embryos to freeze. But we had one embryo…and you only need one.

We had what we were calling our “miracle embryo.” After the transfer, I couldn’t help but believe I was pregnant. I was told to act as if I was. Everything from that moment on felt like a pregnancy symptom. If I was tired, it was because I was pregnant. If I was hungry, it was because I was pregnant. My boob itched for a millisecond while I was showering, obviously, because I was pregnant! I found myself in a Google-black hole—typing bizarre, irrational questions in an attempt to connect elements of my experience to others who had positive outcomes. I was desperately searching for hope.

Unfortunately, hope is not always enough. We did not get pregnant from that cycle and we did not have any frozen embryos. It was as if we didn’t do anything at all. We were exactly where we started (with the exception of being in a little more debt, of course).

Undergoing IVF, for me, was emotionally easier than the years of infertility leading up to it. It was actionable. I felt as if I was doing something. Anyone who has experienced infertility knows that it doesn’t make sense. You don’t start off trying to get pregnant thinking that you won’t. You start off thinking that you’ll be pregnant the first month. After all, its likely you’ve spent most of your sexually active life trying to prevent pregnancy. In my case, I had even denied Rob’s suggestion to get pregnant earlier in our marriage, something I now struggle to accept. “We’re too young. I want to be more stable. I want a career,” I remember telling him.

When you start trying and it doesn’t happen, you resist “infertility” as a concept and instead try to problem solve, as if getting pregnant requires anything more than what we all know it takes. You go through many moments of believing you are doing something wrong—maybe you aren’t tracking things quite right or eating the right foods or taking the right supplements. You think maybe you’re not getting enough sleep, you’re not exercising properly, or you’re too stressed out.  Perhaps the timing is wrong, you need to focus on your career, or maybe there is something wrong with your relationship. You are constantly looking for something to fix. You question whether you should even be a mother; whether you’re a good enough person. You also resent the bad advice people give you (and you will get a lot of bad advice). And, sadly, you become envious of the women who seemed to get pregnant so easily.

Infertility is very isolating. The fact that “a lot of women go through this” (a sentiment iterated almost inevitably any time I shared my experience) never comforted me. For me, being infertile was more than just not being able to have a baby. It was years of fear and pain actualizing itself. It was resentment towards doctors who, for years, didn’t take my concerns seriously.

After the failed IVF cycle I was told that I had a good egg reserve, but sometimes in women who have endometriosis the egg quality may be suboptimal. Endometriosis. This was a term I had heard many times but was never able to claim because a true diagnosis only comes from having a laparoscopy—a procedure in which a surgeon can view a woman’s reproductive organs and perform surgery if needed. I was told that I had “suspected endometriosis” and this was a potential cause of my infertility and pain.  

Almost a decade of pain.

I had my first period at 14. I had my first painful period at the age of 22 and that is the one I will never forget. Up until that point, my periods were pretty insignificant. I had mild cramps but nothing notable. I had no idea that my first painful period would be the first period of every period I would continue to experience for the next seven years and eventually contribute to my infertility. Rob and I were living in Florida at the time, nearly 1,000 miles from our hometown in New Jersey. Rob was in the Navy and was out to sea for a few weeks. I remember being in our apartment when I was hit with the most intense sensation I’ve ever experienced. I was alone, screaming, but there was no one to help me; no one to witness the discomfort. I remember reluctantly calling my mom. At that time in my life I hated asking anyone for help. Because Rob and I were married so young (at the infantile age of 21) I had this deep need to prove (mostly to myself) that I was mature and adult enough to handle everything independently. But even this was too much to go through on my own. My mom advised me to go to the ER. We were insured through the military at the time and the hospital I had to go to was about 30 minutes away. I feared any medical bill I might get by going to a walk-in. I shouldn’t have drove because of the agony I was in, but I didn’t have anyone else to drive me. Not anyone I was willing to be that vulnerable with, to be “too much” in front of. I remember sobbing as I drove, my vision slightly blurry. And when I pulled up to the hospital I called my mom again. The pain was gone. “Should I still go in?” I asked her. I decided not to and instead drove home. I felt crazy. What the hell just happened?

And so it continued. Every month I would have these intense periods—so intense they would sometimes make me vomit. The pain would last anywhere between one to three hours. Rob learned the drill quickly. If he was around he would rub my throbbing legs as I squirmed in a fetal position wrapping my arms around my waist. He also learned that when I said, “I think I’m about to get my period,” that meant we had to stop whatever we were doing, no matter where we were, and go home. There was no way I could endure that pain publicly. The worst part was that the pain was unrelenting. It wasn’t alleviated until it was over. But when it was over that was it, until the next month.

I finally decided to make a doctors appointment after a few months of continued pain. During this visit I described my period pain and the doctor sent me for an ultrasound. I was told the ultrasound didn’t show anything and I was “fine.” And that was it. No other investigation. My pain wasn’t addressed at all. I began questioning myself. Was I just intolerant to pain? Is this normal?  No one else really seemed to be concerned so I just continued to go on with my life. No big deal I guess. 

From then I would see other doctors who would put me on a series of birth control pills, often offering contradictory, inconclusive information. They would suggest, through subtle and passive acts like handing me pamphlets on the topic, that I could potentially have endometriosis.  Not really sure what to do, I would experiment with my diet in an attempt to assume some type of control over a body that felt out of control. I also tried acupuncture as a more natural alternative to pain relief. But nothing really helped. I remember crying once during one of my acupuncture appointments. “Are you concerned that this isn’t working?” the acupuncturist asked me. Yes. I was concerned. It wasn’t working. I was still in pain and I was terrified that there was something really wrong with me. I was tired and I felt completely alone. I didn’t feel as though I was being taken seriously. And I feared that all of this would one day affect my ability to get pregnant—something I always wanted but of course wasn’t ready for at the time. I expressed that fear to my acupuncturist and she said, “If it is endometriosis they’ll just scrape it out when you want to get pregnant. Don’t worry.” #badadvicepeoplegive

It turns out I do in fact have endometriosis. After seven years of pain, two and a half years of infertility, and a failed IVF cycle I sought out an endometriosis specialist. To be honest, I didn’t even realize that an “endometriosis specialist” was a thing; no doctor had ever referred me to one or mentioned that it was something I should seek out. It is difficult to find help for something you are not sure you have. You feel a bit insane. After years of independent research (and the wealth of knowledge I received from those pamphlets along the way…cue sarcastic eye roll) I felt in my gut, both literally and figuratively, that I had endometriosis…but what if it turns out I didn’t? What if it were all in my head?

I became so desperate that I was willing to risk the embarrassment of not having anything “wrong” with me. On April 30th of this year I had my first laparoscopy and an endometriosis diagnosis was confirmed. Endometriosis is a painful disorder in which endometrial-like tissue is found outside the uterus. Symptoms may include painful periods, pain during intercourse, pain with bowel movements or urination, excessive bleeding, infertility, fatigue, bloating, constipation/diarrhea, and/or nausea especially during your period.

Here are some really important facts about endometriosis taken from endofound.org: the exact cause of endometriosis is not known but we do know it is the only known precursor to ovarian cancer; on average, women will suffer at least 10 years before being diagnosed; and federal research dollars amount to only $1.10 per year for each diagnosed woman. (If this information is not shocking, read those facts a second time.) Unfortunately, we don’t know that much about endometriosis not because it is a new disease, but because no one has really cared to investigate female bodies, let alone female pain.

It is only after not being able to do the thing that is expected as a woman—reproduce, carry a child, become a mother—that my pain and fatigue has been considered seriously. I assume partial responsibility for this. I didn’t advocate for myself strongly enough; maybe it was because I was young, ignorant and naïve. But I also believe that, in part, I was conditioned to believe that my pain was invalid and insignificant.  I believed myself to be overdramatic. I believed that maybe I just didn’t tolerate pain well. I believed that I should just deal with it. And I was specifically told by a doctor that I was “fine.” Why would I believe otherwise? 

So now, after seven years, receiving a diagnosis is surreal. I am overwhelmed and having a lot of emotions that I didn’t necessarily expect. I am feeling strongly about the fact that we need to start discussing our reproductive health in a more honest and productive way. According to endofound.org, 7 million women in the US have endometriosis and women with a close relative with endometriosis are 5-7x more likely to also have it yet 60% of women report that they do not discuss their reproductive health with their family.

My experience with endometriosis is certainly not the worst of it. Many women lose their jobs because their pain is so unbearable they can no longer work. Some women have to have organs such as their fallopian tubes or ovaries surgically removed. Some women have full hysterectomies. And some women lose the ability to ever conceive.

There is a part of me that resists wanting to share my experience not only because it is extremely personal but also because I know that other women have it far worse than I do. But I truly believe that not sharing our experience is part of the problem. Suffering in silence is not a badge of courage. Imagine how much sooner girls and women would be diagnosed if we talked about the fact that period pain is not normal. It is no surprise that we don’t discuss it.  I really didn’t. Periods are “gross.” It’s not exactly dinner conversation. And we assume that periods are supposed to be uncomfortable so when someone complains about their period we wrongfully believe we know what they are experiencing. 

But here is the difference: if pain is severe enough that someone mentions it, it is severe enough to be taken seriously. Many women go to their doctors and don’t mention their period at all—and that’s likely because, while it may not be the most enjoyable aspect of their life, it’s also not negatively impacting their life. When someone mentions pain, its because its affecting them and they are looking for answers and solutions.  So whether it is you or someone you love—your daughter, your sister, your girlfriend or your wife, your cousin or your friend—we need to validate people’s experiences. Tell her that she is not being “too much” or “too dramatic” because she probably believes she is. Tell her its okay to be concerned because it is, in fact, concerning! Tell her that you believe her. Tell her it is a big deal.  And help her find the medical care she deserves sooner so that she may not have to endure years of pain, fatigue, possible infertility, or possible surgical intervention that may require removal of reproductive organs.

As for me, I am and will be fine. I am grateful to finally have a diagnosis and the recent procedure should help with both pain and infertility. Rob and I remain hopeful and optimistic that what will be, will be. I am grateful that I have access to information and the resources to afford medical care as well as support from family and friends.

And I am especially grateful to Rob. During our first ever appointment with a fertility specialist last Spring I was asked about my menstrual history. My instinct was to underplay my experience like I always had because I was embarrassed and I didn’t want to be “too much," too overdramatic. Rob immediately picked up on this and respectfully, yet firmly informed the doctor that he believed my pain was severe, not moderate like I had been alluding to. He was a witness to my experience and an advocate for my health…and truly always on my side.

Do We Need to Detox From Sugar?

PSA.

Sugar is not heroin. You do not need to “detox” from it.  

Firstly, detoxification is the process of removing toxic substances from the body. A toxin is an poison or venom which causes disease when present at low concentration in the body. Just to be clear, “detox” is a legitimate medical term and detoxification is provided in hospitals when there are actual life-threatening circumstances such as dangerous levels of alcohol, drugs or poison. The word “detox” has been hijacked by the wellness community under the premise that we are somehow full of toxins—and only if we take x supplement or drink y tea—can we be purified. There is usually a thick layer of weight-loss promises icing this bullshit cake.   

Our body—our skin, our digestive tract, our lungs, our kidneys, and our liver—are pretty efficient at removing waste and other unwanted materials from our bodies. Of course there are ways to support these organs and help them function as effectively as possible but do we need a “sugar-detox?”

Lets first discuss what sugar is.

When people think of sugar, they are generally thinking of a disaccharide called sucrose. Sucrose is cane sugar; the sugar we put in our coffee in the morning or that we use while baking. Sucrose is also added to commercial products to provide sweetness.

But “sugar” is actually an umbrella term that refers to a number of carbohydrates including simple carbohydrates such as monosaccharides (glucose, fructose, galactose) and disaccharides (lactose, sucrose, and maltose) as well as complex carbohydrates such as oligosaccharides and polysaccharides (starches, glycogen, and dietary fiber).  Most dietary carbohydrates are broken down to glucose which is commonly referred to as “blood sugar.”

Hopefully sugar is seeming more ambiguous and the idea of eliminating sugar is seeming more nuanced. When someone says they are eliminating sugar, clarification is needed: are we talking about cutting back on sweets like cookies and brownies or are they talking about sugar on the macro level—including all carbohydrate foods that would eventually be broken down into a monosaccharide? This would include the elimination of high lactose dairy, beans and legumes, fruits, starchy vegetables, and grains including wheat, rye, oats, barley, and rice.  It should be noted that these are all nutrient dense foods. Hard to believe they are “toxic” (cough, because they’re not, cough).

This isn’t to say there isn’t a nutritional difference in foods that contain sugar or that too much sugar can’t have detrimental impact on health. Certainly this is true. For example, lets take the most common source of added sugar in the U.S. diet—sweetened soft drinks. A 12 ounce can of Coke has 140 calories, and 39 grams of carbohydrates all coming from added sugar. The ingredients in Coke are water, high fructose corn syrup (this is the added sugar), caramel color, phosphoric acid, natural flavors and caffeine. There aren’t really any other significant sources of nutrition. There is no fiber, no protein, no dietary fat. It also doesn’t have a significant source of vitamins or minerals. Is soda toxic? No. In fact, if someone were starving or dehydrated…soda would probably save their life. The problem with soda can be chronic overconsumption because it displaces other important nutrients. We also know that a diet high in simple sugars can have a negative effect on blood lipids (cholesterol, triglycerides) and needs to be monitored in someone who has metabolic impairment (someone with prediabetes or diabetes).

Reality is, the main difference between added sugar in commercial products and natural sources of sugar such as those found in fruits and dairy are the additional nutritional benefits of foods that have naturally occurring sugars. Fruit, for example, will also have dietary fiber, vitamins, and minerals. Dairy, such as yogurt for example, will contain a natural source of sugar named lactose but will also contain protein, dietary fat, and vitamins and minerals. Essentially, you are getting more bang for your sugar buck. These additional nutrients also have influence over how our body responds to the sugar intake.

When carbohydrates on the macro level are consumed they are digested, absorbed, and transported through the body primarily as glucose. “Glucose is an essential nutrient for most cells to function properly. The brain and other tissues of the central nervous system and red blood cells are particularly dependent on glucose as a nutrient.” (Gropper)

You see, your body actually likes using glucose for energy and is very efficient at doing so; it has multiple back up plans to maintain homeostasis when energy needs are low.

One such process is called glycogenesis. This is when the body takes glucose that is not needed for immediate energy needs and converts it to glycogen.  Think of glycogen as an energy reservoir. The body stores glycogen in the liver and muscle tissue; when our energy reserve is low (or we have increased energy needs such as during periods of exercise) the body can pull from the reservoir and convert the glycogen back into glucose. This process is called glycogenolysis. Confusing that our body would preserve a substance for future use if the substance were toxic.

Storing extra glucose as glycogen is sometimes not enough of a safeguard so our body has yet another mechanism. A process called gluconeogenesis or the production of glucose from noncarbohydrate sources like protein. Isn’t that wild? Your body has a mechanism to create glucose just in case it doesn’t get it from the diet and it runs out of its reserve.

If the body is almost completely deprived of carbohydrate as a source of fuel the liver begins producing ketones from fatty-acid oxidation. The brain requires a large and constant supply of fuel and in the fed individual, this happens to be glucose. However, during starvation ketone body formation is elevated and becomes the primary source of energy.  This is an “overflow” pathway that may occur in someone with untreated type 1 diabetes mellitus, starvation, or someone implementing a very low carbohydrate diet. Although ketogenic diets have been shown to have some therapeutic effect, individuals implementing a ketogenic diet should be closely monitored by a healthcare professional. “Ketosis can be dangerous because it can disturb the body’s acid-base balance. However, the liver’s ability to deliver ketone bodies to peripheral tissues such as the brain and muscle is an important mechanism for providing fuel in periods of starvation. In short, it is the lesser of two evils.” (Gropper).  

Essentially, your body doesn’t need to “detox” from sugar because sugar is not toxic. Carbs are not the #1 enemy and your body functions pretty well when consuming carbs. What can be helpful is choosing nutrient-dense carbohydrates more often when you can.

Carbohydrates are misrepresented and misunderstood. In my opinion, a “sugar-detox” is an oversimplification of how our body utilizes carbohydrates. It is fear mongering and I don’t see it eliciting sustainable, positive behavior change.

Let me explain why I felt compelled to break this down.

Our society is very focused on “health” and “wellness” so long as its fitting into the ideal. We tend to be far too concerned about someone’s “health” if their body is outside of the ideal or what we have come to deem as “healthy.” On the other hand, people are very congratulatory of those who strive constantly towards a more outwardly acceptable appearance. (Cue Becky’s before and after photo and the slew of Facebook comments telling her how amazing she is regardless of knowing whether the behavior enacted to get there was sustainable or healthy.) The thing is health ain’t got no size y’all!

Do you want to know what I think is more dangerous than sugar? Demonizing sugar. Or any type of food. Placing morality on food. Suggesting that there is a level of purity to be achieved. It’s a lot of hooey and its an ineffective healthcare strategy.

At least 30 million people of all ages and genders suffer from eating disorders in the U.S and at least 1 person dies every 62 minutes as a direct result from an eating disorder. And this is only accounting for those who are diagnosed.  (ANAD)

Sometimes disordered eating behavior can be put in a tiny little box labeled “healthy” and wrapped with a suffocating bow called “wellness.” In my opinion, “sugar-detox” has the strong potential to be that box.

Who is being reached with this broad-sweeping, nutrition propaganda anyway? My hunch is that a “sugar-detox” may appeal to the upper-middle class person who has access to Whole Foods and a farmers market, especially a person who is attracted to diet culture and persuaded by the idea of “getting in shape,” or “losing weight,” etc. But this type of rhetoric doesn’t necessarily translate to the single mom living in a food desert pinching pennies to feed her kids. What usually does trickle down the pipeline is judgement and shame which is likely worse for someone’s health than a chocolate bar. “Wanna know a bigger predictor of disease and health than weight? ZIP CODE. Where you live, what privileges you hold are bigger predictors of health than BMI.” (Hartley)

By using strong, manipulative language with regard to food (such as a “sugar-detox”) we are helping neither the person at risk for an eating disorder nor the person who would benefit from real, legitimate nutrition information.

Remember that part of having a healthy diet is enjoying your food and engaging socially while eating. Its about listening to your internal hunger cues, asking yourself what kinds of foods may satisfy you at any given moment. This may sometimes mean a big salad and other times a big cookie (and sometimes both). Nutrition is not black and white; it is individual. If you see extreme language used with food, question it. Ask yourself if it would actually make you healthy and happy. Ask yourself if it is sustainable long term. Ask yourself if depriving yourself of any type of food has ever worked out in the long-run before.

Check out Intuitive Eating by Evelyn Tribole and Elyse Resch for more information on a balanced eating approach.

References:

Image: https://content.byui.edu/file/a236934c-3c60-4fe9-90aa-d343b3e3a640/1/module3/readings/carbohydrates.html

Advanced Nutrition and Human Metabolism: Gropper, Smith, Groff

http://www.anad.org/education-and-awareness/about-eating-disorders/eating-disorders-statistics/

Antonia Hartly at Instagram handle: @feministnutritionist referencing Linda Bacon